hit and miss
the master of the screen that is clint eastwood has dissappointed me. well he hasn't, but he has. let me explain.
a few weeks back ali and i watched changeling. a true story about a young lady called christine collins from 1920s los angeles. she returns home one day to find her 10 year old son walter gone. he is not found until a year later the police turn up with walter... except it's not him. so begins the tragic story of a mother's unending search for justice, truth and ultimately, her son.


it's a very very moving story and angelina jolie plays the main role incredibly well. i initially thought that she was an odd choice for such a dramatic role, but she nails it and is the best thing about the movie.
* * possible spoiler alert (missing from the trailer) * *
so what was wrong with it? when the storyline about what happened to walter and the other children begins to unfold we are shown events in flashback. kudos to jason butler harner for his role as the serial killer - he is a very nasty piece of work indeed. unfortunately these events are detailed in a too horrifying a fashion. not particularly gruesome, but very strong suggestions and clever editing topped by incredible acting ensured that the feeling of absolute evil and the utter fear in these children at the hands of this sadistic killer is so intense that ali walked out of the movie and i came seriously close to stopping the movie completely on two more occassions (i averted my eyes from the screen instead!) as it was too harrowing witnessing what was happening to these children. when i say these children i obviously mean the 'real' children. the events are true and, maybe it's because of what happened that i (we) found it so unbearable to watch so vivid a portrayal of what they actually went through.
now i am of the opinion that these scenes were unneccessary. that by filming them in such a way and feeling the need to include them in the movie, actually destroyed it. the movie sans flashbacks worked great - fantastic and highly recommended. the movie including flashbacks i cannot recommend as i feel that dirty harry himself has overstepped the mark as to what is suitable/acceptable to put on screen just to prove a point or simply shock the audience. we got the idea about how awful it was for these children without having it rammed down our throat in a most unsubtle way. the point of the movie was, after all, the mother's story and not the horrors that those children underwent. that's the impression i got from the trailer anyway!

0 comments:
Post a Comment